This weekend I took notice to what the first round picks for many team were doing. Many were living up to their potential and talent. Others, may have taken to the bench. I decided to look back on each teams 1st round picks over the last few years, this is what I found.
Miami - The Dolphins have had a couple misfires, but pre-Parcels shouldn’t count. This year they picked up CB Vontae Davis, who isn’t starting, but definitely contributes. 2008’s Jake Long is still developing but still should be an anchor on the O-line for quite a few years. 2007’s Ten Ginn Jr is a hard one to figure out, he’ll have games where his stats are amazing, then you won’t hear about him for weeks. 2006 pick Jason Allen still hasn’t broken into the starting line-up. Miami’s bright spot is 2005 pick Ronnie Brown, who gets running room behind solid T Vernon Carey, taken in 2004.
Minnesota - The Vikings don’t necessarily draft consistently, but man have they picked a couple good ones. This year’s WR Percy Harvin is a play maker. If it’s not catching a pass, then its returning a kick. 2007 gave them a guy that 6 other teams are kicking themselves for passing up. 2006 LB Chad Greenway missed his rookie year, but he’s establishing himself as one of the better defenders in the league ever since. 2005 WR Troy Williamson is labeled a bust. Kenechi Udeze is no longer on the team after being picked in 2004. 2003’s Kevin Williams clogs up the middle quite well. Bryant McKinnie has been a starter since 2002.
New England - Like the Colts, this is not a team worried about finding stars in round one, just role players. Although, 2008 pick Jerod Mayo is one of the better LB’s in the league. 2007’s Brandon Meriweather was just in the highlights for his pick-six this week. Laurence Maroney came along in 2006, but the Patriots have never really leaned nor depended on him. The 4 first rounders from 2003-2005 are all respected starters.
New Orleans - To really evaluate the Saints first round picks, you have to start in 1999. That year they put all their chips into one player – Ricky Williams. Talented? yes. Good investment? no. Two years later they draft Deuce McAllister. He was a good player, but only made it through all 16 games once for the Saints. In 2002, they drafted Donte Stallworth and Charles Grant, both talented, but Grant hasn’t been able to reproduce stats like he did early in his career, and Stallworth (in jail) could be the leading Brown’s receiver right now. Jon Sullivan was a defensive tackle taken in 2003 – currently team-less. Finally in 2004, a pick has proven to be worthy of the first round, as Will Smith is one of the better defensive ends. They got another good pick in 2005 with T Jammal Brown, a pro-bowler, although out for this season with injury. We’re all still trying to figure out if 2006’s Reggie Bush can actually be a star, or just a situational playmaker. Robert Meachem (2007) needs to step up and not be lost among the many Saints receivers. Sedrick Ellis is developing into a decent DT in only his second season. Malcolm Jenkins was the top corner taken this last year, but his learning curve is hitting a few roadblocks with various injuries.
NY Giants - Thinking they needed help here, they took receiver Hakeem Nicks with their first pick. Turns out they had a couple other younger guys step up this season. Nicks will have to wait his turn. Last year’s Kenny Phillips seems to have potential, but has been injured this season. CB Aaron Ross is the same story in his third season. 2006’s Mathias Kiwanuka got to start last season with Umenyiora on IR, but has to go back to reserve role now. 2004 produced the infamous Rivers-for-Manning swap. Which didn’t seem so good the first couple years, but Eli has started living up to his famous name (that trophy helps). None of their first rounders before him are still with the team, although 2002’s Jeremy Shockey is a name worth mentioning.
NY Jets - The other NY team looked like they made the best pick in the draft for the first 3 weeks, although still not a bad choice, Mark Sanchez has looked a lot more human. 2008’s Vernon Gholston and Dustin Keller are young but still need to prove they were worthy of first round picks. 2007’s Darrelle Revis is quickly making a name for himself this season. 2006 was a big year as neither T D’Brickashaw Ferguson nor C Nick Mangold has missed a start since being drafted. Interesting note, the other ‘big year’ for the Jets was 2000’s draft. Out of the four taken in the first round, only DE Shaun Ellis is still with the team.
Oakland - Well lets see…Darrius Heyward-Bey. I don’t want to be too hard on him, it’s not his fault he’s fast. Darren McFadden – the first runningback out of a stable of backs taken last year, has produced the least. 2007 – JaMarcus Russell, at least they got a good tight end in the second round. 2006’s Michael Huff lost his starting SS position last year, but has seemed to want to play this season. Fabian Washington, their CB taken in 2005, is now a Raven. 2004’s disappointment Robert Gallery has played slightly better since moving to guard. You’ll have to look to 2003 for a good choice, CB Nnamdi Asomugha. Although, the very next pick, DE Tyler Brayton is now a starter for the Panthers.
Philadelphia - This isn’t a team that tends to pick the “marquee” positions in the first round. They knew they needed to get another weapon for Donovan, so Jeremy Maclin seems like a good pick, and he has contributed well in his first few games. The Eagles didn’t have a first rounder for the previos two years, but picked up DT Brodrick Bunkley in 2006. He’s now in his 3rd year of starting, playing alongside 2005’s DT Mike Patterson. When these guys hit their peak together, the Eagles will be hard to go up the middle on. Shawn Andrews was taken in 2004. While pro-bowl caliber, he’s been an oft-injured guard. You’ll have to look to 1999 for the next first rounder still with the team. Despite what some fans think, I’m pretty sure it was a good choice to get McNabb.

Recent Comments